What in God's name is this typesetting?

Base +13, Beddhist +17, Deep in +6, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, theprinceh +9, Oupzzy +6, 58569 +6, Captian Katsura +7, MJTH +8, Imocla +9, Runedude +9, and 17 more...

>doesn't understand Japanese
>claims it's 95% accurate
>god awful editing on top of it
>wants to scam people out of their money eventually

Ok lol

rough translation

Page 1
OG: 私が入社するのは世界的大企業「ロボナノ社」
TL: "I will be joining the world's largest company, Robonano."
ED: it's just a global company

Page 15
Your TL: it feels so good when i thrust my cock
JP: シゴくと
Intent: Does not mean thrusting.

Page 15
Your TL: Something's coming, something like pee, let's shoot it out
JP: なんかきてる おしっこみたいなの出そう
Intent: 出そう in this form here doesn't mean "let's" but rather "seems like". Also, it would make more sense to qualify the FEELING as being similar to peeing, not the actual stuff coming out.

Page 15
Your TL: My head's spinning
JP: くる
Intent: Does not mean spinning. Not even close, in fact. No mentions of heads either.

Page 15
Your TL: Oh fuck!
JP: おぉ
Intent: I'm not giving you this liberty because taking liberties would mean actually understanding the original meaning, which you obviously don't.

Page 15
Your TL: My pussy is dripping
JP: ほぉん
Intent: That's a groan.

Page 16
Your TL: this ejaculation... after all
JP: これ・・・射精・・・やっば
Intent: She's remarking how cumming feels crazy good.

Page 16
Your TL: Reina cock
JP: レイナ♥チンポ♥
Intent: Classic case of a line that's waaaay too contextual to be literally translated, else it's nonsensical. It's also connected to the following line. "Reina.... let's use our cocks..." // "Use our cocks to blah blah"

Page 16
Your TL: Im coming coming
JP: シコシコシコ
Intent: Does not mean coming, and it's also another line that's heavily context reliant and has to be expanded in English to make any sense.

Page 14
Your TL: we are squeezing each other's cocks
JP: お互いのチンポをシゴくんだったな
Intent: Does not mean squeezing and also wrong tense.

Page 12
Your TL: Swing
JP: 礼
Intent: Does not mean swing.

Base +22, dankestdungeon +24, cybeast93 +22, GeminiJ -6, avikdas99 +10, proxy +7, Zed01 +13, Deep in +6, IcyaIex +5, TheGoodGiggle +12, Osipov Lev +11, warsyty +2, Woody Pack +6, and 51 more...

>good enough translations
I don't know what dimension you're living on where this is considered "good enough", but this ain't it, chief.

Base +7, The_Minotaur +6, proxy +7, Zed01 +13, as102 +13, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, theprinceh +9, blueperfection +8, danielwain +9, NewhalfIsMale +10, 58569 +6, and 18 more...

10th error for rough TL

001
OG: 私が入社するのは世界的大企業「ロボナノ社」
TL: "I will be joining the world's largest company, Robonano."
ED: it's just a global company

Base +31, dankestdungeon +24, cybeast93 +22, TheGoodGiggle +12, Osipov Lev +11, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, theprinceh +9, 58569 +6, Captian Katsura +7, Tryndamere95 +19, WildCrow +13, Jouven +8, and 3 more...

cutegyaru
Thank you for your help I'll edit those pages accordingly and double check the rest before posting them

Over all what would you give the translation? flat out F or like a D-?

any and all criticism welcome

Last edited on 07 April 2023, 02:50.

Base +6, bluemana -6, MrFinkel -6, Alaephant -8, FFTHEWINNER +6, Morgan the man -6, IS IRIS -6, Woody Pack -6, Jalis -7, theprinceh -9, murgilod -6, TheGameBoy50 -11, Sindas -6, and 20 more...

@demented39
Your translation is a big fat 0.

Considering how poorly EVERY line is translated. you'll have to prove how exactly you've attempted to correct this if you ever update the gallery.. All I did was give you a small sample.

If you want real honest feedback: go learn Japanese.

edit: at this point you're just begging people to translate FOR you. you're clearly not ready for this shit.

Last edited on 07 April 2023, 04:34.

Base +22, dankestdungeon +24, cybeast93 +22, avikdas99 +10, Zed01 +13, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, theprinceh +9, blueperfection +8, NewhalfIsMale +10, 58569 +6, Gentleman Chimera +8, and 15 more...

are you an alt account of https://e-hentai.org/g/2353305/5c4ab3ec67/ or just falling for the same false advertising by whatever tool you're using? this is the 2nd time I've come across an MTLer claiming exactly 95% accuracy out of hundreds that I've tagged

Base +31, dankestdungeon +24, cybeast93 +22, avikdas99 +10, Zed01 +13, Deep in +6, as102 +13, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, the dru one +7, 58569 +6, Captian Katsura +7, and 12 more...

There's a phrase, "something's better than nothing," but this is just appallingly incompetent, and I am genuinely afraid that this doujin is less likely to receive a legitimate translation because of the chance of someone seeing this in passing and thinking it's already been translated.

Base +7, Deep in +6, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, blueperfection +8, the dru one +7, 58569 +6, TheGameBoy50 +11, Not Benedict +6, spartan10000 +6, Th3 Sl0th +6

I truly do not understand why people who don't speak the language want to do translations. Because you're clearly not passionate about this kind of thing. If you WERE you'd use a machine translator, get a rough jist of what everyone is saying, and then just rewrite their dialogue to something that is actually coherent in English. The translation wouldn't be accurate or good, but at least the final product would be readable.

Like, it really seems like you just ran it through whatever machine translator you used, and then didn't even bother proofreading it. What, is that too much work to do? And if it isn't and you just don't know how, then why bother doing this at all?

Like, what the fuck is this? What possessed you to go out of your way to make something this bad? And then go through the trouble of uploading it?

Base +6, Beddhist +17, Deep in +6, as102 +13, TheGoodGiggle +12, IS IRIS +6, Woody Pack +6, JoyPanda +8, xyg9449 +6, blueperfection +8, Rembdar +6, danielwain +9, nommhaj +8, and 12 more...

@Tatchy I tried to translate and rewrite in such a way to maximize its coherence over accuracy and after rereading the pages i've posted i feel as if I achieve that in most pages, could you give an example of text or pages that don't make sense so that i can correct them? thank you in advance!

@cutegyaru I haven't asked anyone to translate for me I asked for feedback on potential mistakes in grammar and coherence that i may have missed or may be unintentionally over looking

Last edited on 07 April 2023, 04:45.

Base +6, Alaephant -8, biscardone -8, Morgan the man -6, IS IRIS -6, Woody Pack -6, Jalis -7, theprinceh -9, nommhaj -8, murgilod -6, Sindas -6, dankestdungeon -24, far1432 -6, and 14 more...

I refuse to believe that any person who has ever read manga would look at this typesetting and translation and think, "Yeah, this is acceptable." For the sake of my faith in humanity, I hope you are a troll.

Base +6, TheGoodGiggle +12, Woody Pack +6, blueperfection +8, nommhaj +8, Gentleman Chimera +8, TheGameBoy50 +11, ziggyb +7, thowok +6, Not Benedict +6, Th3 Sl0th +6, IngmarS +7

@demented39 how'd you get the 95% accuracy number? even if you take it out of the current version it's still viewable in the parent gallery

Base +31, dankestdungeon +24, Woody Pack +6, blueperfection +8, TheGameBoy50 +11, Not Benedict +6, Th3 Sl0th +6

@rsx205 I wasn't really going for accuracy. At the time of posting I believed that the text that I missed, rewrote, or mistranslated didn't hurt the general understanding of the story and was negligible enough not to take away too much from the overall quality of the translation, but it seems that i was woefully incorrect which is why I went ahead and deleted that claim in the child gallery. I suppose that would make this more of a rewrite though.

Last edited on 07 April 2023, 06:37.

Base +6, dankestdungeon -24, Morgan the man -6, Mr_Person -18, IS IRIS -6, Woody Pack -6, Jalis -7, theprinceh -9, CocoNord -4, coolie5000 -11, Alaephant -8, murgilod -6, rabbit alpha -6, and 20 more...

This translation was so bad it made my dick invert

Base +6, Woody Pack +6, nommhaj +8, NewhalfIsMale +10, TheGameBoy50 +11, IngmarS +7

@demented39 brother, your translation is so terrible even the title of the manga is wrong.

I'm not gonna correct it for you. Go learn what you did wrong yourself.

Base +7, dankestdungeon +24, IS IRIS +6, Woody Pack +6, John Silker +6, blueperfection +8, the dru one +7, nommhaj +8, TheGameBoy50 +11, Th3 Sl0th +6, IngmarS +7

Well nice attempt but...this translation is not good.

Base +6

While I’m all for criticizing bad translation, some of you have shown you guys know Japanese. Why not stop bitching and just translate it yourself? Fuck.

Again: I understand criticizing someone, but at the same time, complaining on the internet has shown to never be productive.

Edit: I figured I’d get down-voted for my comment lol.

Last edited on 07 April 2023, 20:04.

Base +6, chibifrostblaze -8, kingkarus -6, coolie5000 -11, Alaephant -8, murgilod -6, Gentleman Chimera -8, Oupzzy -6, animadversion -6, Red/Jack -25, gamaroguar -11, nommhaj -8, Argonisgema +6, and 51 more...

@Eric Keldrev
If you BOTHERED to click on my profile or rsx205's, you'd easily realize we're active and productive translators (and this is just a partial sample. most of our projects are uploaded by different accounts). You have 0 uploads and never contributed anything anywhere.

The reason we're not "translating this ourselves" is because we're fucking busy. If we were to retranslate every bad translation out there we'd be doing this 24/7. Use your brain.

Base +22, Garadice +7, murgilod +6, Gentleman Chimera +8, Imocla +9, Oupzzy +6, Ahegaosensei +6, TheGameBoy50 +11, Not Benedict +6, JoyPanda +8, kagezoro +6, Erosanagi +6, sovair11 +6, and 18 more...

The OCR translator I originally read this with had a better & more faithful translation than this thing

Base +4, JoyPanda +8, IngmarS +7

guess cunningham was right

Base +6, Slarka -10, far1432 -6, nommhaj -8, murgilod -6, Alaephant -8, WildCrow -13, CompleteWeirdo -6, viserdes -7, Sky boy -6, Novalaxia -6, crazyfrogdom -7, asdfmovies -6, and 3 more...

YOU EVEN ARE NOT WILLING TO USE SOME GOOD WEB TRANSLATOR LIKE CHATGPT!

Base +6, IngmarS +7, SomeUne -6, barea100 -6, Th3 Sl0th -6

you really are fucking demented

Base +8, blueperfection +8, IngmarS +7, nommhaj +8, Oupzzy +6, barea100 -6

dude, just like, disown the gallery and stop updating it, lol. What's the point of re-type setting ONLY the first page??? (it's still ugly, btw)

Base +7, IngmarS +7, Slarka +10, nommhaj +8, Jouven +8, Sky boy +6, barea100 -6

cutegyar: most people know since you insist to comment in galleries you might not read/comment if not due to the tl itself. his point is you don't provide translation of this specific story. That doesn't dismiss your critic but we dont have any incentive to like other version.

Base +14, CompleteWeirdo -6, murgilod -6, blueperfection -8, Novalaxia -6, Fills -6, crazyfrogdom -7, animadversion -6, Meta Arc -6, Alaephant -8, Ownerer -6, Th3 Sl0th -6, IngmarS -7, and 2 more...