As much as I like Hayate Yagami doujins and appreciate new ones, this one feels unimpressive and underwhelming despite rarity of Hayate doujins.

Base +23

@lightshader
I know what you mean. The cover looked promising, but judge a book and so on.

Base +30, Marupinku +8

While some artists have evolved immensely over the years, others just recently begun or simply don't have THAT much talent. This isn't that bad, in fact, go back 10 years and this would be considered pretty darn good. We're some lucky pervs, regularly spoiled by amazing works, to an extent where material like this doesn't trigger our "senses" as efficiently.
Thanks for the upload of course. There are always fans of the style.

Base +14