translated by biribiri biribiri.fakku.io

@Fang5: I'm pretty sure he didn't realize he loved her. She was always next to him and only after he lost her, he realized his feelings, but it was too late already, so he distanced himself from her so he didn't suffer.

@rozzak: Indeed, they weren't together, but the whole book is full of retrospections, you can see for example her bursting in tears at the beginning, because she still waited for MC to call her and stop her, then all the story is explained, to come back around the time the other guy explains that he loves the heroine and such. Then there's more of time or place-leaps. It was hard to catch changes in narration >_>

Literally just a shoujo manga tbh.

Last edited on 15 October 2016, 22:20.

Base +6, skeksis +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, hswhat +6, Wilfriback +14, traversal +11, 58569 +8, zkxhfpdk -13, waltergeist +9, jfragrettel +8, bigmak +6, wantdemloli +10, georgef35 +6, and 4 more...

I dont see this as NTR anymore! That dude lost her on his own accord.

Base +6, bggm +22, MaouMaou +9, Syokool +8, Traniz -7, Machiga -7, 58569 +8, biscardone +7, GarethMars +7, aiwotorimodose +26, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk -13, jfragrettel +8, and 2 more...

I don't understand this Kii-chan guy's feeling at all. Does he see the girl as just siblings? Or does he actually have a feeling for her?

The way the artist presented him, he actually only sees the girl as a sibling. When he saw her playing flute with the other guy, he's just like "They're attracted to each other. Huh, okay". Thus he tried to distance himself so the girl can develop her feelings more to the other guy. If that is so, what I don't understand is why he didn't just straight up said so to the girl, instead of just stayed silent. It's like he's trying to give the girl's unrequited love a hope just to torment her.

All in all, from all of Mashiraga Aki's NTR story, this is on the weaker side.

Base +7, Wilfriback -14, biscardone -7, NoAngel +6, zonedout93 +6, pandoraman +10, zkxhfpdk -13, Zuasfadas +5, jfragrettel +8

Well, if this qualifies as NTR, it's one of the better ones. Doesn't really rely on bullshit just to move things along, the characters feel a bit more believable, there isn't a stock NTR protagonist, villain, or dumb girl. Hell, even the fact that there's no 180 flip featuring rape -> love is really impressive.

Not too shabby, I must say.

Base +7, Ooe Kintarou +6, ss567 -6, stygan +7, rext11 +6, Wilfriback +14, Machiga -7, HentaiM@ster +8, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, Zuasfadas +5, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28

melancholy end

Base +1, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28, MelmothTheWanderer +8

This isn't netorare. She did not cheat on him. They weren't even in a relationship. Who the heck randomly tagged NTR just because they are salty?

@TheDiabolical

I think it is important to classify this as non-NTR because I find it to be a good end. Kii is obviously a dumbass who just didn't realize what he had lost until he lost it. Personally, I am glad that she moved on, because Kii is honestly an asshole for dragging things out. She moved on and found happiness with the other guy. If there was NTR, I would be feeling a bit of guilt for feeling so happy, but there isn't NTR, so it's not sad.

@Rozzak

I'll take your word for it. Doesn't stop me from feeling absolutely happy about her moving on. Kii needs to understand that life doesn't sit still. If he wants something, he can't just wait for it to fall into his hands. When I mean happy, I mean personal happiness not the character's. I feel joy that it turned out like that. Because I think she gained true normal happiness, which in turn made me happy. Occasionally NTR does make me happy, but that is when the guy is totally pathetic like this guy. So whether this is NTR or not, it makes me happy. Happy End.

Last edited on 16 October 2016, 01:38.

Base +7, distels -11, Machiga -7, skeksis -6, Darknemo2000 -21, NoAngel -6, zkxhfpdk -13, waltergeist -9, elvendrunk -11

Doujinshi - http://www.doujinshi.org//book/760683/

Toranoana - http://www.toranoana.jp/mailorder/article/04/0030/27/11/040030271172.html

Melonbooks - https://www.melonbooks.co.jp/detail/detail.php?product_id=115813

Base +7, Ooe Kintarou +6, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8

@DarrenC123
The "N" in the title stands for netorare. I'm gonna trust the nip author's judgement on his own work this time. If it makes you feel better, she didn't completely get over the MC-kun until her boyfriend fucked her. And even if she didn't technically "cheat", it appears both childhood friends felt romantically towards each other, they were bf/gf in everything but name.

>Implying netorare can't make you feel happy for the girl
Netorare is about the boys' suffering. In most cases I'd wager the girls will be relatively happier with their new fat, bald, giant-cocked boyfriends.

Last edited on 16 October 2016, 00:44.

Base +6, bggm +22, Ooe Kintarou +6, ss567 +6, kurzwaltz messer +6, stygan +7, waltergeist +9, rext11 +6, Wilfriback +14, Machiga +7, skeksis +6, biscardone -7, NoAngel +6, and 7 more...

All these artist works are labeled ntr some should be but this one nope.

Base +6, waltergeist -9, Machiga -7, biscardone +7, NoAngel -6, zkxhfpdk -13, cochrane -21, MelmothTheWanderer -12, elvendrunk -11

This is quite a melancholy work, but are people talking about how they felt about it? Or why the guy stood by and did nothing until he lost the girl's heart completely?
No. It's all "This isn't NTR!" and "Why is the NTR tag on this?!", bitching on and on. Is having something being considered NTR by someone anywhere ever really such a curse to you that it's all you guys care about? Seriously.

Base +6, Machiga +7, murraymints999 +6, zkxhfpdk -13, jfragrettel +8

More translated Mashiraga Aki is always appreciated! Thank you very much biribiri.

Base +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, distels +11, Machiga +7, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28, MelmothTheWanderer +12

Did she forget he? The girl might regret thinking that she still loves the friend and go back. In the manhwa H-mater, saeyoung still loves her ex-boyfriend and uses another man to forget him, but can't. She still love Taebong.
She may be trying to forget his friend believing that she have no chance with him.
.
@ Fang5
He misses his presence and her friendship, I believe that when she began dating another boy she left aside.
I receive a once the confession of my childhood friend who wanted to date me, but I had no attraction for her and I was dating another girl. She broke off her friendship with me, I missed her company, but I didn't want to be her boyfriend.

Last edited on 16 October 2016, 03:28.

Base +2, Machiga -7, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8

I hope that translate the Matsuri Zenpen and Matsuri Kouhen -

Last edited on 16 October 2016, 03:12.

Base +1, Cy48 +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, waltergeist +9, jfragrettel +8

I think it's netorare. The childhood friend did distance himself from her because of jealousy, seeing that she was "already attracted" to the other guy.

It's a very mild NTR though, because she's not being "stolen" as much as choosing the guy who has proven he cares about her more.

I mean, come on, even Shu from netoraserare had the testicular fortitude to tell the girl how he felt. She practically confessed her feelings for him and he still didn't respond so in that way, I don't feel pity for the childhood friend at all.

Base +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8

@badmana I think it was less jealousy and more of him being the epitome of the "nice guy" stereotype. You know, that whole "I just want her to be happy, even if it's not with me..." betaboy mentality. I see the exact same sort of plot circumstances in a lot of shoujo manga. It's something like:

>Mutual love between childhood friends
>Male doesn't want to lose his relationship to youthful indiscretion (because of some herbivorous "cherishing you"/"I don't want to lose you as a friend" bullshit)
>Female doesn't realize the reasons for him withholding his affections
>Female inevitably gets courted by a good guy
>Male mistakes one-sided feelings (other guy) + friendship (female) as an indicator of the change in her affections towards the opposing side of the love triangle
>Female gets asked out by other guy
>Male queues up that "I just want her to be happy" mentality and tries to be supporting towards (what he thinks is) their mutual love
>Female is like "fuck you then", and starts dating other guy (because he's a good friend/she wants to get over her past love/last-ditch effort to incite some jealousy)
>6 months later she's about to fuck her boyfriend and is like "I obviously love you so why don't you stop me like one of those shoujo bishies!!?!"
>Male is like "dafuq...I thought she loved that other bloke...wtf bitches are tricky"
>Because of his shitty adolescent brain he doesn't have the courage to break the already established relationship between her and her boyfriend (especially when they're on a nice lil trip together)

>Male uses some sophistry about "just hearing her flute is good enough for me" to drown out the fact that he totally can tell that her and that other guy were fucking each other's brains out all summer.

All-in-all I gotta hand it to the girl's boyfriend. Dude loved this girl enough to deal with osananajimi affection-levels for the MC the entire time that they were dating. He played the long game and came out on top. Very commendable. Those months that they were dating must've been pure torture.

Base +6, rext11 +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, Askhandar +7, EmpiresEnd +6, wantdemloli +10, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28, randomname777 +6, Hyoros -15

Honestly forgotten about this doujinshi until now. It's not netorare. The girl moved on from her wimpy childhood friend and be with a boyfriend that can satisfy her.

Base +13, distels -11, biscardone +7, zkxhfpdk -13, waltergeist -9, cochrane -21, MelmothTheWanderer -26, elvendrunk -11

OMFG please translate the other stories as well.

Base +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, jfragrettel +8

The guy can regain childhood friend with in hentai When you let go of my hands by takenoko seijin.

https://e-hentai.org/g/31846/109c859a35/

Base +1, Machiga -7, deadarm +6, waltergeist -9, MelmothTheWanderer -26, elvendrunk -11

"One time, in band camp, I shoved an entire flute up my..."

Base +4, Ooe Kintarou +6, camaleon666 +6, waltergeist +9, jfragrettel +8, randomname777 +6, your_name +6, deth212 +6

Eeeeh.... This seems less like NTR and more like two people making a decision about their relationship. :/

Base +7, Morgoth666 +7, biscardone +7, zkxhfpdk -13, jfragrettel +8

I feel bad for the new guy. Her mind was still by her childhood friend when he stuck it in, and also nearly the entire time during the intercourse. Also her last sentence doesn't feel like she moved on completely.

Base +13, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8

I think we see countless retellings of this plot in shoujo manga, because it's a very "clean" way of having a love-triangle in which the childhood friend loses without demonizing anyone involved. Definitely a hackneyed formula, but certain shades of plausibility still make for an effective emotional gut-punch. Many can probably empathize. Sometimes, the sincere reasons you pursue something ends up for naught; sometimes, people don't realize what they have until it's gone and quietly cope.

I do appreciate this for the balance of plot and setup vs. hentai sex.

As for the NTR, I'm with the "not" NTR side. Regardless of the childhood friend's herbivore status, regretting a past opportunity is not theft.

Base +7, biscardone +7, zkxhfpdk -13, jfragrettel +8, Hyoros +15, deth212 +6

i dont feel that this is a NTR but still the artist's work FORK in the ROAD 2 is the best NTR for me.

Base +2, zkxhfpdk -13, akunoko -28, MelmothTheWanderer +12, elvendrunk -11

I, for one, support the childhood friend in his actions.

He isn't interested in her that way, he refused her confession, he showed no regret and no jealousy towards their relationship, and he happily kept his distance.
If anything, she's the one who shows regret, she wanted more of their relationship, she was shot down, and in the ending, she still shows lingering desires towards him, who cares not.

Base +15, biscardone +7, jfragrettel +8, FijiWater -6

The girl lost hope that he would be with his childhood friend, though still like him, he does not feel physical attraction to her, he only has affection for her friend.
For him want to flirt with she, has to have physical attraction.

Base +3, jfragrettel +8, Hyoros -15, kIsho Acrerion Orion -7

Oh, I had been waited this translation for a long time. Thanks you for translating it. Well, Mashiraga Aki is one of the best NTR artists ever.

This story is so sweet, bitter, and mixed many emotions in it. Sometime when you think you are very familiar with NTR as that time NTR strike you with mighty emotional hammer.

Base +6, Ooe Kintarou +6, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, jfragrettel +8

Very well produced the history and verisimilitude.

Without using clichés like rape, drugs, mind control, mindbreak and other clichés used in these stories, if worth much more emotions like frustration, fear, anger, loneliness, angst and despair in the construction of narrative and in the actions of the characters.

Base +1, Rouge･ -30, biscardone +7, ss567 -6, Ooe Kintarou +6, zkxhfpdk +13, cochrane +21, akunoko -28, MelmothTheWanderer +8

I don't know about you guys but this is not NTR for me.

The "MC" is a retarded beta.

The "NTR guy" is actually a good, honest guy.

The girl is not a whore or something like that,.

Base +6, GarethMars -7, zkxhfpdk -13, waltergeist -9, cochrane -21, deth212 -6, elvendrunk -11

Since this is one of those realistic stories, here are my thoughts on it. I didn’t make me rage but I did feel a bit sad. Not due to the fact that the CF didn’t get the girl but because he lost a friend. From my experience friendships with the opposite genders don’t last due to hormones and the girl (or guy) wanting a relationship. Even if they are still on speaking terms it won’t be the same. That’s what I felt bad about the most in this story.

Thinking about the aftermath of what could happen (I’m not saying this will happen, Just a guess) The relationship between the two won’t last long because this girl in particular couldn’t have her CF because of him lacking confidence while not making a move. Which leads to another issue. Since she couldn’t have her CF she appears to be settling for the first nice guy to come along. In other words, she is only interested in the idea of being in a loving relationship, not the person himself. Since she couldn’t have the one she originally had feelings for, now she just wants a relationship to forget about her CF.

That’s pretty sad. A friendship you had your whole life wiped out in an instant just because you didn’t end up together. In this case the girl chose the first nice guy that came along. I have nothing against him or anything. I never could understand how a lifelong friendship could end so easily just because of a relationship.

In short, they won’t last because the girl ONLY appears to want a relationship so she can forget her CF as well as being in love with the idea of being in love. Also the CF did srew up by not calling her for a long time, but if she was that concerned about it why didn’t she call him? Please tell me if I’m missing something here.

Base +5, OrinKiller7 +11, StealthyJarl +4, zkxhfpdk +13, deadarm +6, jfragrettel +8, cochrane +21, akunoko -28

don't see much ntr here, just three dumb kids.

Base +7, zkxhfpdk -13, waltergeist -9, MelmothTheWanderer -26, Hyoros +15, elvendrunk -11

Well this is quite the unusual NTR. The girl getting fed up with her childhood friend's wishy washyness and petty jealousy, and choosing someone who actually voiced his feelings instead of just fucking her.

This is good. Really good. Yhe NTR was fully emotional. The dumb childhood friend in this case only has himself to blame.

Base +8, bggm +23, Ooe Kintarou +7, Yossarian762 +7, zkxhfpdk +13, deadarm -6, jfragrettel +8, deth212 +6, akunoko -28

@"this isn't NTR" folks
Congratulations! You've discovered you don't have a NTR fetish! You have a disgusting old man + slut + mindbreak fetish. Good luck!

Base +6, Wilfriback +15, zkxhfpdk +13, Zuasfadas +4, Askhandar +7, jfragrettel +8, cochrane +21, deth212 +6, akunoko -28, Hyoros +15, Mao M. +6

The girl like of the her childhood friend, but he didn't corresponded her, she sought to fill the void of sue heart with another boy. I can't believe that the boy will be able to fill the void in her heart and she will search your childhood friend, because she loves him.
No is just girl want someone else to fill in her heart, but if the other person is going to get.

Base +2, StealthyJarl +4, deadarm +6, jfragrettel +8

This girl will face an existential void feeling missing from her friend.

Base +2, deadarm +6, jfragrettel +8

Very melancholic ending. I can understand the guy's dilemma. He really didn't know how he felt about her until he lost her, feelings can be very complex and I'm sure many have been in his position before.

Base +7, rurikoko +6, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28, GO_KENTA +9, MelmothTheWanderer +12

This is a really nice take, they had a small romance, lets say 20 affection points but it was all the love they had so they were the most important person to each other, then the guy distanced himself and the girl developed a relationship with the other guy and her love towards the second guy was higher so even if the love towards the first guy is 20 points the love towards the second one is like 50+ points and on the rise

At that point the relationship with the first guy never changed and it probably never will

Base +8, jfragrettel +8

@Gamma 102
"Thinking about the aftermath of what could happen (I’m not saying this will happen, Just a guess) The relationship between the two won’t last long because this girl in particular couldn’t have her CF because of him lacking confidence while not making a move."

Now THAT would make a better story than this, to be honest. I don't think this is bad, but it's sort of bland and predictable compared to Musa. To add to that, the artwork isn't as hot as Fork in the Road. At least a sequel would be desirable. Though, it'd probably still be pretty cliched.

Base +6, jfragrettel +8

less NTR, more like guy wasn't honest with himself, shot himself in the foot, letting another guy (who wasn't a dick) take her

Base +6, jfragrettel +8, akunoko -28, MelmothTheWanderer +12

Im not suprised no one give a shit to a fucker boy. He is the real victim one here. He confessed to the girl, but the girl still wishy-washy about it until they got into the action. Imagine after you got laid for a whole summer, and the girl still has lingering feeling toward her osanananajimi. I would be discouraged because of that.

The real question, is the girl already moved on or still got tiny bit of hope on her osananajimi?

Base +6

There is ZERO Netorare / NTR in this story!
It is a sweet story about a girl letting go of her childhood crush and moving on to a boy that cares for her.

Base +6, MelmothTheWanderer -26, Hyoros +15, elvendrunk -11